Student Response System Comparison
J'aime 0
Lien | ViaResponse | TurningPoint | Top Hat | Socrative | Sendsteps | Shakespeak | Reef Polling by I>Clicker | Qwizdom | Poll Everywhere | OMBEA | Infuse Learning | i>Clicker | Echo360 | ClassQuestion | ARSnova |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Company Info | |||||||||||||||
| Image |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| Corporate Website | turning.com | tophat.com | socrative.com | sendsteps.com | shakespeak.com | reef-education.com | qwizdom.com | polleverywhere.com | ombea.com | infuselearning.com | iclicker.com | echo360.com | classquestion.com | arsnova.eu/... | |
| Voting technology | Web Based/App | Clickers/Web/App | Web Based/App | Web based | Web/SMS | Web/SMS | Web Based/App | Clickers/Web/App | Web Based/App | Clickers/Web | Web Based | Clickers/Web/App | Web Based/App | Web/Web App | Web Based |
| Student License Cost | $20 6 months | Licenses available at $20.99/1yr or $37.00/4yr. | $24 for 4 months, $36 for 12 months, or $72 for 5 yrs. | Free version (50 cap.); Pro version $59 per instructor (150 cap. per activity) | Free up to audience of 20 € 15 per extra audience member per year | Free up to audience of 20 € 0.10 per extra audience member per year. | First 14 days are free. $9.99/Term $15.99/1yr $21.99/ 2yr $31.99/4yr | QVR Student App purchase: $9.95/yr or $24.95/5yr Q6 Clicker: Student purchase $49, no ongoing costs | Free | $18-yr for web, $40 per clicker | Free | Lifetime clickers are $30.99/$41.99 (free 6-month access to the mobile solution included) | Free | Free for students and teachers | Freeware GNU License |
| Capture d'écran |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING | 3.0/5 1 note | 3.3/5 4 notes | 4.3/5 8 notes | 3.0/5 2 notes | 5.0/5 1 note | 5.0/5 2 notes | 2.0/5 5 notes | aucune note | 2.8/5 4 notes | 4.3/5 6 notes | 3.0/5 1 note | 3.4/5 5 notes | 3.5/5 2 notes | 5.0/5 1 note | aucune note |
| -- Presentation Tool | Non | Oui Hardware and software options available to control presentations and polling. | Oui Can present through PowerPoint using the Top Hat widget | Non | Oui Integrates within PowerPoint | Oui Integrates within PowerPoint | Oui Present with anything (slides, video, website, etc.). No import of content required. | Oui PowerPoint Integration and Survey Bar works over web or most software applications | Oui Can Integrate Polls with PPT | Oui Easy to use PowerPoint integration and standalone software for KeyNote, Google Slides etc. | Non | Oui Present with anything (slides, video, website, etc.). No import of content required. | Oui Can present with uploaded slides | Oui Presentation is web-based | Non |
| -- Asynchronous Content Access | Non | Oui Self-paced options for hardware and app. Create and deliver any type of assessment. | Oui Files in Classroom Module | Non | - Can send session history with questions, images, and answers to student to be used as a study guide outside of class. | Oui Self-paced mode for both QVR (response app) and clickers. | Non | Non | Oui | - iClicker Reef/Cloud- Can send session history with questions, images, and answers to student to be used as a study guide outside of class. | Oui Slides and videos can be accessed anytime | Oui Students have access to question history and their answers | Oui | ||
| -- Student Performance Analytics | Oui | Oui Various reports available to monitor student or class progress. | Oui Gradebook with student performance - Students and professors have access to their own accounts | Oui Limited | Oui Various reports available to monitor your audience and see exam results | Oui Various reports available to monitor students and see exam results | Oui REEF Analytics - Insight to usage across your campus, department, and classrooms | Oui | Oui | Oui | Oui Limited | Oui Campus Analytics - Insight to usage across your campus, department, and classrooms | Oui Large amount of student engagement analytics | Oui View charts of student results and fully featured gradebook | Oui |
| -- Advanced Question Types | Oui | Oui Many options available including WordCloud, competition polling options, comparative slides, and essay. | Oui 6 question types: Multiple Choice, Word Answer + Word Cloud, Sorting, Numeric, Click on Target, Matching | Non | Oui Multiple choice, open, wordcloud, quiz questions, survey functionality | Oui Multiple choice, open, wordcloud, quiz questions, survey functionality | - Most popular features used by instructors included | Oui Text Input, Numeric, Equations and Mixed Expressions | Oui Mul Choice, Word Cloud, Q & A, Rank order, Image, Survey, Open ended | Oui | Oui | Oui Multiple Choice, Short Answer, Numeric, Target, Anonymous Survey | Oui Multiple Choice, short answer, Image,ordered list, numerical | Oui Multiple choice questions, polls, correct answer/participation tracking | |
| -- Student to Student Interaction | Oui Discussion Tool | Non | Oui Discussion Tool, Anonymous Discussions | Non | Non | Non | - REEF Quizzing (beta) - Incorporate group activities and collaborative learning | Non | Non | Non | Non | Non | Oui Student Answered Q's | Non | |
| ADMINISTRATIVE FEATURES RATING | 4.0/5 1 note | 4.5/5 2 notes | 4.2/5 5 notes | 2.0/5 1 note | 5.0/5 1 note | 5.0/5 2 notes | 2.8/5 5 notes | aucune note | 4.0/5 1 note | 4.8/5 5 notes | 2.0/5 1 note | 4.0/5 2 notes | 4.0/5 1 note | 5.0/5 1 note | aucune note |
| -- Integration with LMS | Oui | Oui Direct integrations available for leading LMS. Sync rosters and export grades instantly to LMS. | Oui Direct integrations available for leading LMS. Sync rosters and export grades instantly to LMS. | Non | Oui Seamless LMS integration available Excel reports | Oui Seamless LMS integration available Excel reports | Oui Seamlessly integrate with all major LMS platforms, including Blackboard Learn, Canvas, Desire2Learn, Moodle, and Sakai. LTI available. generate Excel reports of aggregate and individual response data. | Oui Blackboard, Moodle, Eduphoria Aware, Extramarks, Accuity, and PLATO | Oui | Oui | Non | Oui Seamlessly integrate with all major LMS platforms, including Blackboard Learn, Canvas, Desire2Learn, Moodle, and Sakai. LTI available. generate Excel reports of aggregate and individual response data. | Oui LTI integration in Blackboard | Oui Export to any format, Canvas quick export option | - |
| -- Campus Wide Funding-Option | Oui 10K-1000 Students | Non | Oui $30K-50K for17000 FTE | Oui Free | Non | Oui € 5500 unlimited students and teachers | Oui Campus-wide licensing available | Oui Yes. Campus wide funding for QVR. Request a Quote. | Oui $3500-1000 Students | Oui $7000-$20000 | Oui Free | Oui With Reef/Cloud | Oui $10K-1000 Students | Oui Free | Oui Free |
| -- Vendor Faculty Support | Oui | Oui Dedicated training team for implemention and extensive online documents and information for all users. Online chat and phone support available. | Oui Extensive Online Doc's, and Question Form | Oui Online User Guide | Oui Dedicated support team | Oui Dedicated support team | Oui Comprehensive online materials and dedicated support | Oui Contact Tech Support via Phone or Online Ticket, Online Reference Materials | Oui Institution has Acct Manger | Oui | Non | Oui Comprehensive online materials and dedicated support | Oui | Oui Online support and user guides | Oui Free |
| -- Accessibility Features | Non | Oui ResponseWare offers screen readers. Hardware option available for the visually impaired. | Oui ADA readers | Non | Oui 15 languages | Oui 15 languages | Oui | Oui | Non | Oui | Oui Multiple Languages | Oui Has Voluntary Product Accessibility Template (VPAT) | Oui Many capabilities within Blackboard- also has ASR and ability for outside notetaker. | - | Oui 2 languages |
| -- FERPA Compliant | Oui | Oui Enhanced security and encryption to ensure all student information is secure. | Oui | Non | Oui Enhanced security and encryption to ensure all student information is secure. | Oui Enhanced security and encryption to ensure all student information is secure. | Oui | Oui | Oui | Oui | Non | Oui | Oui | Oui | Non |
| STUDENT FEATURES RATING | 2.0/5 1 note | 4.0/5 2 notes | 4.3/5 4 notes | 2.0/5 1 note | 5.0/5 1 note | 5.0/5 2 notes | 3.7/5 3 notes | aucune note | 3.0/5 1 note | 4.3/5 6 notes | 1.0/5 1 note | 3.0/5 2 notes | 4.0/5 1 note | aucune note | aucune note |
| -- Vendor Student Support | Oui | Oui Online step-by-step registration documents. Phone support and online chat available. | Oui Extensive Online Doc's, and Question Form | Non | Oui Online support portal with FAQs, videos, user guides, etc. | Oui Online FAQs, support tickets and reference materials | Non Online Docs | Oui Comprehensive online guidebook. | Non | Oui Online support portal with FAQs, videos, user guides, etc. | Oui | Oui Dedicated student support channel | Oui Free | ||
| -- Game Interaction | Non | Oui Competition features available for teams or individuals. | Oui Tournament with leaderboard | Oui One preset game | Oui Play quizes and see who wins | Oui Play quizes and see who wins | Non | Oui 4 game options, Fast Track, Baseball, Mission to Mars and Quandary (Jeopardy Style) | Oui Competitions with MC Questions | Oui Competitions with leaderboards | Non | Non | Non | Non | Non |
| -- Multiple Device Compatibility | Oui | Oui App available for Android and iOS devices. Web browser option available for browsers. | Oui SMS option for basic cell phones, smart phones, tablets, computers | Oui | Oui Use within PowerPoint only. Answering can be done on any device via web or sms | Oui Use within PowerPoint only. Answering can be done on any device via web or sms | Oui Any smartphone, tablet or laptop with a Web browser. iOS app, Android app, and works alongside i>clicker + and i>clicker 2 | Oui Use clickers alongside QVR response app. App is available for any web-enabled device. | Oui | Oui Clickers + any web enabled device | Oui | Oui i>clicker +, i>clicker 2, REEF Polling (any smart device) | Oui Web Based, iPad App | Oui Works on phones, tablets, laptops, almost anything with a web-browser | Oui |
| -- Feedback to Teacher | Non | Oui Devices and ResponseWare allow for communication to the teacher. | Oui Instant Feedback to teacher, everything is saved in the Gradebook, can compare sessions or questions | Non | Oui Survey functionality integrated for students to fill out | Oui Survey functionality integrated for students to fill out | Oui | Oui | Non | Oui | Non | Non | Oui | Oui Ability to make survey-like questions | Oui |
| -- Text/SMS Response | Non | Non | Oui Yes - offline mode and SMS option | Non | Oui Includes SMS responding | Oui Includes SMS responding | - No SMS, but does have short answer up to 140 characters | - No SMS, but short text answer option is available. | Oui | Oui | Non | - No SMS, but does have short answer up to 16 characters | Oui | - No but short answers supported | Non |
| Commentaires | Direct PowerPoint integration or poll over top of any application. Clickers and ResponseWare work in the same environment to meet the needs of all learners and environments. | Integration of PowerPoint, questions, pages, discussions, and quizzes. Really easy to use. Provides one-on-one training for professors. | Il est possible d'utiliser les exposants dans l'éditeur de texte, mais aucun autre symbole. | Direct PowerPoint integration, 15 languages, very easy to use. You can find tutorials on this link: sendsteps.com/en/how-it-works | Direct PowerPoint integration, 15 languages, very easy to use. You can find tutorials on this link: sendsteps.com/en/how-it-works | The mobile-optimized engagement solution that works alongside traditional i>clicker remotes if needed | With over 30 years of industry experience, Qwizdom audience response solutions offer the highest performance and reliability. | Multiple Language Support | OMBEA displays live feedback on people’s opinions and knowledge. It’s super-easy to use with your Microsoft PowerPoint slides for voting, engagement and assessment. | Market leading hardware known for it's simplicity and reliability. All remotes work alongside the mobile solution, REEF polling, to create a blended classroom if needed. | Completely free (donation supported). Easy to use and works on devices students already own! | Very cool! | |||
| Squarecap |
6 plus
Avis utilisateurs et commentaires
Chab0tais le 9 mar. 2022 09:26:49 a noté Socrative: Appréciation 5/5 
DP le 11 avr. 2019 18:45:44 a noté Reef Polling by I>Clicker: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 1/5 
DP le 11 avr. 2019 18:45:35 a noté i>Clicker: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 1/5 
DP le 11 avr. 2019 18:45:25 a noté Poll Everywhere: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 1/5 
DP le 11 avr. 2019 18:45:14 a noté Top Hat: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 1/5 
Laura le 7 déc. 2018 15:57:56 a noté TurningPoint: ADMINISTRATIVE FEATURES RATING 5/5 
Laura le 7 déc. 2018 15:57:29 a noté TurningPoint: STUDENT FEATURES RATING 5/5 
Laura le 7 déc. 2018 15:57:17 a noté TurningPoint: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 5/5 
acor07 le 2 aoû. 2018 19:38:50 a noté ClassQuestion: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 5/5 
acor07 le 2 aoû. 2018 19:38:40 a noté ClassQuestion: ADMINISTRATIVE FEATURES RATING 5/5 
44503 le 11 mai 2018 18:24:01 a commenté TurningPoint 
Sam le 14 déc. 2017 23:37:43 a noté Poll Everywhere: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 5/5 
Gert Andersson le 25 jul. 2017 17:29:00 a noté OMBEA: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 5/5 
Gert Andersson le 25 jul. 2017 17:28:52 a noté OMBEA: ADMINISTRATIVE FEATURES RATING 5/5 
Gert Andersson le 25 jul. 2017 17:28:42 a noté OMBEA: STUDENT FEATURES RATING 5/5 
Gert Andersson le 25 jul. 2017 17:28:27 a noté i>Clicker: ADMINISTRATIVE FEATURES RATING 5/5 
Gert Andersson le 25 jul. 2017 17:28:19 a noté i>Clicker: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 5/5 
Gert Andersson le 25 jul. 2017 17:27:48 a noté OMBEA: Rating 5/5 
electra7210 le 21 jul. 2017 19:06:01 a noté Top Hat: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 3/5 
electra7210 le 21 jul. 2017 19:00:54 a noté Socrative: PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES RATING 5/5
voir les commentaires plus anciensSimple et rapide dans l'appropriation tant du formateur que de l'élève
Great products, used them for years. Made work easier when it comes to gathering colleagues input instantly, and honestly. They even have very detailed reports that can be used for discussion and record keeping. We used them when do do new hire training, community outreach, voting and assessments.
You can start teaching with this tool in minutes. It's fast and you can incrementally supplement lectures. It's also super versatile.
Expensive! Difficult to change slides on the fly.