 Link | Nightingale | Guayadeque | XBMC | Clementine | Rhythmbox | Exaile | Banshee | Quod Libet | gmusicbrowser | Listen | JaJuk | aTunes | Amarok 2.x | Amarok 1.4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marchio globale | no rating | 5.0/5 1 rating | 5.0/5 1 rating | 3.7/5 3 ratings | 3.0/5 2 ratings | 3.5/5 2 ratings | 3.5/5 2 ratings | 5.0/5 2 ratings | 3.0/5 1 rating | 4.0/5 1 rating | no rating | 2.0/5 1 rating | 2.0/5 1 rating | 5.0/5 1 rating |
| Estratto | Nightingale chirps your favorite tunes! A beautiful interface with a wide range of supported audio formats, all with multi-platform support! [Notye: Songbird's fork ! (now that Songbrid's development is closed on Linux)] | Guayadeque is a music management program designed for all music enthusiasts. It is Full Featured Linux media player that can easily manage large collections and uses the Gstreamer media framework | XBMC is an open source digital media hub designed to be a media player for the living-room TV. Its graphical user interface allows to easily manage video, photos, podcasts... using a remote control. | A cross-platform music player inspired by Amarok 1.4 | An integrated music management application, originally inspired by Apple's iTunes. | A music player and manager written in Python. It incorporates automatic fetching of album art, lyrics fetching, Last.fm scrobbling, support for tabbed playlists, many portable media players, internet radio such as shoutcast. | A music and video player which can manage your podcasts, Internet radio and keep your portable device loaded with good stuff. | An audio player designed around the idea that you know how to organize your music better than we do. | An open-source jukebox for large collections of mp3/ogg/flac/mpc/ape files, written in perl. | A music management and audio player for GNOME | Organizes and plays music. It is a full-featured application geared towards advanced users with large or scattered music collections. | A full-featured audio player and manager, developed in Java | An audio player with many exciting features | |
| Vantaggi | ||||||||||||||
| Svantaggi | crashes too often (on my PC at least) :( | |||||||||||||
| Reviewed version | 1.11.1 (Ubuntu 12.04) | 0.3.1-1639 (Ubuntu 11.10) | 0.7.1 (Ubuntu 11.10) | 2.90.1 (Ubuntu 11.10) | 0.3.2.2 (Ubuntu 11.10) | 2.2.0 (Ubuntu 11.10) | 2.3.2 (Ubuntu 12.04) | 1.1.9 (Ubuntu 12.04) | 0.6.5 (Ubuntu 11.04) | 1.9.1 (Ubuntu 11.04) | 2.0.1 (Ubuntu 11.04) | 2.5.0 (Ubuntu 12.04) | 1.4.10 (Ubuntu 11.04) | |
| Player | ||||||||||||||
| ReplayGain | Sì option: Album/Track | Sì option: radio/album/off modes and preAmp | Sì options: pre-ampli and Radio/Album modes | Sì [plugin] options: pre-ampli and Radio/Album modes | Sì usual options | Sì no options | Sì options: pre-ampli and default ampli | Sì | No Not seen in preferences... | No Not seen in Preferences... | Sì option: Album/Track | No External script - not stable | ||
| Transitions | Sì options: in and out lenghts, in volume, in start => graphical view :) | Sì configurable | Sì option: length | - Only using unstable "unified" sound engine | No | No | No | Sì | Sì | - Only on Stop | Sì options: Transition [NO (blank length) OR YES (length, always OR auto change only OR manual change only). FadeOut [NO OR length] | |||
| Gapless | Sì configurable | No | No | - Only using unstable "unified" sound engine | Sì no options | No | No | No | No | No | ||||
| Equalizer | Sì Presets & Custom | Sì Presets & Custom | - 3rd party plugin (not easy to install) | Sì Presets & Custom | Sì Presets & Custom | Sì plugin | Sì | Sì plugin | No | Sì | Sì | |||
| Navigator | ||||||||||||||
| Mode de navigation | Many and configurable (you can save display presets): Chained lists (configurable) AND/OR TreeView (many modes) AND/OR sources ... | TreeView (up to 3 levels among album, artist, albumartist, genre, year, filetype, albumyear, composer) | Chained lists (Limited to Artist/Album OR Genre/Artist OR Genre/Artist/Album) | TreeView (Limited to Artist, Album, Genre/Artist, Genre/Album, Year/Artist, Year/Album, Artist/Year-Album) | Chained lists (Artist/Album only), but album can be displayed as text or image (by default) | Chained lists (Grouping/Genre/Artist/Album) | Many CONFIGURABLE modes !! Check it out | Chained lists (Artist/Album OR Genre/Artist OR Genre/Artist/Album) | TreeView (Artist/Album OR Genre/Artist/Album OR Album OR Year/Artist/Album OR FileSystem) | TreeView (up to 3 levels among album, artist, genre, artistalbum, composer, label) | TreeView (up to 3 levels among album, artist, genre, year, albumyear, composer, label) | |||
| File | Sì | Sì Library only | No | Sì | No | Sì | Sì Library only | No | Sì Libary only | Sì | Sì | |||
| Cover Navigator | Sì | No but there is a cover manager that can replace, though not handy | No | Sì | - Slows down app a lot, but it can be disabled | Sì | Sì | No | No | No but there is a cover manager that can replace, though not handy | No but there is a cover manager that can replace, though not handy | |||
| Library | ||||||||||||||
| Multiple folders | Sì | Sì | - Yes, but not easy to manage. Use gconf-editor: apps > rhythmbox > library_locations | Sì | No | No | Sì | No | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | ||
| Watch folders | - can only scan at startup (option) or manually | Sì | - Only new files | No | Sì plugin | - Only startup scan (option) or manual scan | - can only scan at startup (option) or manually | Sì | Sì | Sì | ||||
| Statistics | playCounter, lastPlayed, added, rating | playCounter, lastPlayed, score, rating, skippedCounter | playCounter, lastPlayed, added, rating | playCounter, lastPlayed, added, rating | playCounter, lastPlayed, score, rating, skippedCounter, lastSkippedDate | playCounter, added, lastPlayed, skippedCounter, rating | playCounter, lastPlayed, score, rating, skippedCounter, lastSkippedDate | playCounter, lastPlayed, added | playCounter, lastPlayed, firstPlayed, score (optional), rating (optional) | playCounter, lastPlayed, score (optional), rating (optional), added | ||||
| Playlists | ||||||||||||||
| Playlists | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | ||||
| Smart | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | ||||
| Dynamic | Sì Called "Smart mode": auto-fills queue with a given playlist (you can exclude another playlist too) | Sì | - But when the queue is empty auto plays a file from the navigator (selected artist/album/genre) | - No options !? | Sì | No | Sì | - No options !? what source ? | Sì | Sì | ||||
| Queue | Sì | Sì separate window. | Sì | No | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì separate window. | ||||
| Tags | ||||||||||||||
| Editor | Sì | Sì | No Updates only database, not files. | Sì | Sì | Sì Full-featured | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | |||
| id3 version | 2.4 | 2.4 | N/A | 2.4 | 2.3 | ?? | 2.3 (default) OR 2.4 | ?? | 2.3 | ?? | 2.4 | |||
| Auto tag tools | Sì MusicBrainz (artist/album names) + covers (Google, Amazon, last.fm OR Discogs) + lyrics (several choice) | Sì MusicBrainz (audio print) + covers (Last.fm) | - With some plugins only | - Only convert first letter uppercase | No cover and metadata (plugins - no options) + BPM detection (built-in) | Sì From path only. MusicBrainz, CDDB, cover search plugins | - Probably with plugins | No | Sì NOT configurable. No choices displayed. Not handy. | Sì MusicBrainz, Filename | - MusicBrainz but seems outdated | |||
| Scrobbler | ||||||||||||||
| Last.fm | Sì | Sì | Sì plugin | Sì plugin | Sì plugin | Sì plugin | Sì plugin | Sì | Sì plugin | |||||
| Libre.fm | Sì | No | Sì plugin | Sì plugin | No | Sì plugin | No | Sì | No maybe a plugin | |||||
| Internet | ||||||||||||||
| Lyrics | Sì many sites | Sì many sites | - ==> TBD !!! | - Lyrics Fly only (does not work well) | - Only on a separate window | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | |||||
| Biography | Sì last.fm | Sì many sites incl. wikipedia, last.fm, ... | Sì last.fm | No | No | Sì | Sì wikipedia | Sì Wikipedia | Sì wikipedia | |||||
| Photos | - only one from biography | Sì | No | No | No | No | - Only one from biography | Sì | - Only one from biography | |||||
| Online sources | ||||||||||||||
| Online radio | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì plugin | Sì | No | Sì | Sì | Sì | ||||
| Podcasts | Sì | Sì | No | Sì | No | Sì plugin | Sì | No | Sì Balado | Sì | Sì | Sì | ||
| Jamendo | Sì | Sì | Sì plugin | Sì plugin | No | No | No | Sì plugin | Sì | No | ||||
| Magnatune | Sì | Sì | Sì plugin | No | No | No | No | Sì plugin | Sì | No | ||||
| Last.fm | No | Sì | Sì | No | Sì | No | No | Sì | Sì | Sì | ||||
| Libre.fm | No | No | Sì | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | ||||
| Others | icecast, somaFM | Plugins: eMusic, Ubuntu One, Amazon, Internet Archive, Miro | Librivox.org, Amazon | |||||||||||
| Altre | ||||||||||||||
| Plugins | No | No | Sì Most features are plugins | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | - Plugin system not very stable | |||||
| Visualisations | No | Sì | No | No | No | No | Sì plugin | No | Sì | |||||
| Karaoke | No | No | No | Sì plugin | No | No | Sì | No | No | No | No | |||
| Exclusive | Configurable Web links, commands and "copy To". Configurable shortcuts. | Wii Remote control, Transcoder | Add. 3rd plugins exist. Check website. Not always easy to install. | Video, BPM computing (plugin), import Rhythmbox, AmaroK, iTunes (plugin), Audio books (plugin), | Regex-based search. Tag editing allows to edit all kind of tags, though not that user-friendly. | Interface highly customizable. ReplayGain analysis. | ? | |||||||
| Global shortcuts | Gnome Multimédia shortcuts | Gnome multimedia shortcuts OR configurable shortcuts | ==> TBD !!! | Gnome multimedia shortcuts (plugin) | Multimedia shortcuts (plugin - not reviewed yet ==> TBD) | Gnome multimedia shortcuts | Configurable, homemade | ? | "Win"+ shortcuts by default. Configurable. Did not manage to make multimedia keyboard to work. | "Win"+ shortcuts by default. Configurable. Did not manage to make multimedia keyboard to work. | ||||
| Ubuntu (gnome) integration | Sì | Sì OR Custom OSD | Sì | No Custom OSD | - No OSD, but appears in Volume control (plugin) | - No OSD, but appears in Volume control | No Custom OSD | Sì OR Custom OSD | No Custom OSD | |||||
| Other systems | ||||||||||||||
| Windows | No | Sì | Sì | No | - dev | - beta-quality technology preview | Sì | No | No | Sì | Sì | - with KDE for Windows (dev) | - with KDE for Windows (dev) | |
| macOS | No | Sì | Sì | No | - dev | - beta-quality technology preview | Sì | No | No | Sì | Sì | - no official support | No | |
| Dettagli tecnici | ||||||||||||||
| License | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | MIT | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | GNU GPL | |
| Programming language | C++ (wxWidgets) | C++, Python | C++ (Qt) | C | Python (GTK+) | Mono C# (Gtk#) | Python (GTK+) | Perl | Python | Java | Java | C++ (Qt) | C++ (Qt) | |
| Database | Sqlite (~/.guayadeque/guayadeque.db) | Sqlite (~/.xbmc/userdata/Database/MyMusic7.db) | Sqlite (~/.config/Clementine/clementine.db) | XML (~/.local/share/rhythmbox/rhythmdb.xml) | Exaile's custom binary file (~/.local/share/exaile/music.db) | Sqlite (~/.config/banshee_1/banshee.db) | Custom, non-relational binary file (~/.quodlibet/songs) | Custom INI/Tab separated file (~/.config/gmusicbrowser/gmbrc) | Undefined, maybe "proprietary" binary file ? (~/.config/listen/songs.db) | XML (~/.jajuk/collection.xml) | XML (~/.atunes/repository.xml) | Sqlite (default) (~/.kde/share/apps/amarok/collection.db) or MySQL (on demand) | MySQL or Sqlite (~/.kde/share/apps/amarok/collection.db) | |
| Static Playlists | in database (how?) | XSPF (XML) in ~/.kde/share/apps/amarok/playlists/ | ||||||||||||
| Dynamic Playlists | N/A | |||||||||||||
| Smart Playlists | in database (how ?) | |||||||||||||
| Engine | gstreamer | gstreamer | gstreamer | gstreamer. What is "Unified" one ? ==> TBD !!! | gstreamer | gstreamer OR mpg321/ogg123/flac123/amixer OR mplayer | mplayer for all environments, xine for Linux systems | gstreamer | xine | |||||
| id3 library | TagLib | TagLib | N/A | ==> TBD !!! | taglib-sharp | homemade (done by gmusicbrowser author) | JAudiotagger | ==> TBD !!! | TagLib | |||||
| Distribution | ||||||||||||||
| Ubuntu software-center | Sì | No But a PPA exists on official website | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì Default application | Sì | Sì | Sì | Sì | No But a debian package exists on official website | Sì | Sì Using a PPA: http://raphael.camus.free.fr/wiki/index.php?title=Amarok | |
| Ubuntu one-click install | apt://guayadeque | apt://clementine | apt://rhythmbox | apt://exaile | apt://banshee | apt://quodlibet | apt://gmusicbrowser | apt://listen | apt://jajuk | apt://amarok | ||||
| External Information | ||||||||||||||
| Sito web | guayadeque.org | xbmc.org | clementine-player.org | gnome.org/... | exaile.org | banshee.fm | google.com/... | gmusicbrowser.org | listen-project.org | jajuk.info | atunes.org | kde.org/en | kde.org/en | |
| Wikipedia | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | ||||
| Ubuntu-fr | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... | ubuntu-fr.org/... |