Tableau comparatif des logiciels de prototypage et maquettes

Entreprises > Dévelopement informatique
2015-10-08 22:14:44

Si vous avez besoin de dessiner des diagrammes, faire des croquis/maquettes pour des site webs ou des interfaces, il existe beaucoup d'application ou de web apps qui offre cette fonctionnalité.

Dans cette liste nous comparons App Sketcher contre Axure vs Balsamiq Desktop vs Cacoo vs Concept Draw vs Denim vs Designer Vista vs FairBuilder vs ForeUI vs HotGloo vs Inpreso vs iPlotz vs Justinmind vs Justproto vs Lovely Charts vs LucidChart vs Lumzy vs MockFlow vs Mocking Bird vs MockLinkr vs Mockup Builder vs Napkee vs OmniGraffe vs Pencil vs ProtoShare vs Simulify vs Website Wireframe vs WireframeSketcher

Ce tableau est collaboratif n'hésitez pas à le corriger ou l’améliorer.

AloukaApp SketcherAxureBalsamiq MockupsCacoocodiqaConcept DrawDenimDesignerVistaFairBuilderFluid UIForeUIHotGlooIndigo StudioInpresoiPlotzJustinmindJustprotoLovely ChartsLucidChartLumzyMockFlowMocking BirdMockLinkrMockup BuilderMockup PlusMockupScreensNapkeeOmniGrafflePencil Firefox Add onPidocoPowerMockupProcessOnProtoShareSavah AppUXPin
Site webhttp://www.alouka.comhttp://www.appsketcher.com
Offre gratuiteOui- 14 days (free trial)- 30 days (free trial)NonOuiOui- 21 days (free trial)Oui- 20 days (free trial)Non- 15 days (free trial)OuiOuiNonOuiOuiNonNonOuiOuiOuiNonOuiNonOui 30 days Free trialOui Watermarked trialNon- 14 days (free trial)- 31 days (free trial)NonOui Free- 15 days (free trial)OuiOui Up to 30 days fully functional trial
  • 14 days free trial
  • $99 single user
  • Free updates for life
$589 Licence perpetuel unique
  • Desktop:
    • $79 Single user
    • Volume discounts available
  • Hosted:
    • $12/mo for 3 Active Projects
    • $24/mo for 10 Active Projects
    • $49/mo for 20 Active Projects
    • $99/mo for 50 Active Projects
    • $249/mo for 100 Active Projects
  • Gratuit:
  • format d'export: PNG.
  • Historique d'édition: non disponible.
  • Feuilles autorisées: 25.
  • Dossiers partagés: 1.
  • Editions partagées: Maximum 15 utilisateurs par schéma, Max 3 utilisateurs par dossier partagé.
  • Gestion utilisateurs: non disponible.
  • Administrateurs multiples: non disponible.

  • 49$ / an:
  • format d'export: formats vectoriels supportés, PDF, PPT, PS, SVG, PNG.
  • Historique d'édition: oui, et surlignage de différence.
  • Feuilles autorisées: illimitées.
  • Dossiers partagés: illimités.
  • Editions partagées: illimitées.
  • Gestion utilisateurs: non disponible.
  • Administrateurs multiples: non disponible.
  • Free Plan
  • Basic: Starting at $16/Month
  • Pro: Starting at $33/Month
  • Team: Starting at $30/Month
  • Free 21 days Trial
  • $199 ConceptDraw Project
  • $249 ConceptDraw PRO
  • $499 ConceptDraw Office 2
  • $219 ConceptDraw Mindmap V7
  • Price: $79.99
  • 20-days Free Trial
  • Desktop, Web, Mobile and Sketch Mockups
  • Windows, .NET, Java Swing, SWT, Office Ribbon Mockups
  • Websites, Silverlight, Sharepoint, YUI Mockups
  • iPhone, Phone 7, Android Mockups
  • Desktop and Web Sketch GUI Mockups
$99 perpetuel
Free (up to 10 pages and 1 project) Lite ($12 / Month) Standard ($29 / Month) Professional ($49 / Month)
  • $150 single user
$7/mois Simple
$14/mois Equipe
$48/mois Entreprise
1 projet gratuit
V1 Totally Free Forever; V2+ on Yearly Subscription Basis (TBA)$79/anGratuit en ligne
$75 logiciel
$495 par utilisateur
  • $14/month (Standard)
  • $35/month (Plus)
  • $69/month (Unlimited)
$29/an version premium
  • Free (max 60 objects)
  • $4.95/month: Personal
  • $9.95/month: Professional
  • $25/month: Team
GratuitGratuitGratuitGratuit (jusqu'à 10 images)
$19/mois (images illimitées)
Free Online version, Desktop version installs from Online version
  • Trial - free
  • Profressional - $39
  • Team - come soon
  • $99 Single
  • $249 3x
  • $599 10x
$49 et plus
  • 14 days free trial
  • $99.99 individual license
  • $199.99 individual pro license
  • $149.99 family license
  • $299.99 family pro license
  • 31-day free trial!
  • Starter $12 per month
  • Standard $25 per month
  • Premium $55 per month
  • Platinum $175 per month
  • Single License: $39.95
  • Small Team License: $119.95
  • Team License: $199.95
Freeware$29/mois par utilisateurFree
  • Free fully functional trial
  • Starter - 12$ per month
  • Freelancer - 29$ per month
  • Team Effort (most popular) - 49$ monthly
  • Company Wide - 89$ per month

Depending on the number of projects and users you wish to have.
Note globale5.0 1 note0 aucune note4.7 7 notes4.3 7 notes5.0 2 notes0 aucune note5.0 5 notes0 aucune note4.0 1 note0 aucune note5.0 1 note5.0 1 note4.5 4 notes5.0 2 notes0 aucune note0 aucune note4.8 4 notes5.0 1 note0 aucune note5.0 2 notes4.0 1 note3.7 3 notes5.0 1 note0 aucune note5.0 2 notes0 aucune note0 aucune note0 aucune note0 aucune note5.0 1 note5.0 1 note0 aucune note0 aucune note0 aucune note5.0 1 note3.5 2 notes
Version testéeBetaAxure RP Pro 6.0Balsamiq desktopConceptDraw Office 2 ConceptDraw PRO 9 ConceptDraw MindMap 7 ConceptDraw Project 52.0Always up-to-date with no additional costs
Mode déconnectéOuiOuiOuiOui able to continue editing even if the connection with the server has been disconnected - modifications will be saved when connected againOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiNon It's an online application.Oui LucidChart Chrome app allows for offline modeNonOuiOui FreewareOui Nice offline mode support.OuiOuiOui HTML Export to simulate prototypes offlineOuiOui Diagram drawing can be automatically saved at offline mode.NonOui Data potection against sudden internet connection loss
Flow DiagramsOuiNonOuiOui ERD, UML, ORM, FlowChartsOuiOuiOui Storyboards, In-Screen Interaction Flow, and Project FlowOuiOuiNonNon Note yet plannedOui With team version , you can review and workflow.OuiOui Many diagram types supported, real time collaborate with others.NonOui You can design flow diagrams in UXPin as they were wireframes easily. You can also upload a file with a diagram done with any software and include it in your project documentation.
APIOuiNonOui Offered as part of the enterprise packageOui File Format is XMLOuiNonOui JSONOuiNonNon-
Sharing/FeedbackOui (Beta) Secure sharing for discussions and gathering feedback by uploading to Built-in Free Hosted Prototype Sharing and ExportsOuiOuiOuiOuiOui Feedback via PowerPoint's review features; sharing possible via SkyDrive or SharePointOui Diagrams can be shared to other sites and embed to blogs.OuiOui
AnnotationsOuiOuiOuiNonOuiOuiOuiOuiOui Notes - also delivered via emailOuiOuiOui pins and notes + chat with smart conversation historyOuiOui annotations, chat, commentsOui Available in review / presentation modeOui Nice Reviwer and Commets manageOuiOuiOuiOui Comments and inline chating supported in diagraming.Oui Developer Annotations & Reviewer CommentsOuiOui
Generate Documentation/SpecificationsOuiOuiOui Generate Annotated Prototypes Today; PDF Coming/In ProgressOuiOui DOCX, RTF, PDF, HTMLOuiOui *.png, *.pdf,*.pos...-
Master TemplatesOuiOuiOui- Implied Masters in Screens; Cross-Screen Masters PlannedOuiOuiOui Master pagesOuiOuiOui Using PowerPoint Slide MastersOui Templates for different categories. BPMN, UML, mockups, ORG, Venn...OuiOui Yes, enabled by the Smart Element feature
Master ControlsOui Use masters to create reusable design elements (headers, footers, etc.) Unlimited masters on a page and nesting is supported.Oui- Coming in V2 TimeframeOuiOui Yes, enabled by the Smart Element feature
Predesigned Mockup Templates1000+ TemplatesYes there are templates in all librariesComes with built-in samples you can customize; others published on blog ( and in help topics.A complete set of examples is available at: gallery is presented and sharedTemplates provided . Massive diagram resources shared in the diagram library.
Predesigned Icons bundled5000+ IconsFull list available here: than 300, searchable, categorized vector-based icons.Icons for iPhone, iPad and Android150+ iconsBeta: Fontawesome iconsYesMore than 100 wireframe icons includedbunches of icons to be choosed, also support to insert from local.Yes, including Font Awesome (old and new), Pixle Icons.
Favorites Controls LibraryOuiOuiOui
Widgets LibrariesOuiOuiOui 75 built-in user interface components, 187 icons, plus a whole lot of community-generated componentsOui many stencils including ones for iPhones and AndroidsOuiOui Desktop, Tablet, Wireframe, iOS8,Android 5,Windows 8, Apple Watch,Google Glass,Android Wear,Galaxy Glass,PebbleOui Resource: Symbols, Pictures, Templates (tbc)Oui Many built-in, interactive controls, stencils, and shapes, plus custom shapes.Oui Yes, also able to develop custom widgetsOuiOui Currently 63 built-in components, over 200 iconsOui drag & dropOuiOui Drag & Drop ComponentsOui Yes, 22 drag & drop libraries
Custom LibrariesOuiOuiOuiOuiOui Yes ability to customize and save your own widgetsOui Custom Element (*.fce) & Library (*.fcl)Oui Custom Template Library (tbc)OuiOuiNon Not supportedOuiOui Add Mini-Masters or Custom Widgets thru HTML, CSS & JavascriptOui Yes, users can make use of the Smart elements feature, wich enables them to make custom, reusable across whole account elements
Click-Through PrototypesOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOui yesOuiOuiOui Simple as pie; and easily add rich animations if you like.OuiOui Fully interactive and clickable projects.OuiOui Fully interactive and clickable prototypesOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOui
Export de fichiersOui PDF, PNGOui HTML/CSS/JavaScript in a Zip fileOui PDF, HTML, DOCX, PNGOui PNG, PDFOui PDF, PS, SVG, PNGOui HTML, CSS, jQuery in a .zip fileOui PDF, SVG, PNG, JPG, PPT, VDX, and many moreOui HTML,Adobe PDF, Image (PNG, GIF, JPEG)Oui Print full size screens and screenflows, .png, .svg, HTML prototypeOui PDF, PNG, JPG, BMP, GIF, DHTMLOui *.pdf, *.pngOui PNG; HTML Prototype Generation in Beta; PDF Coming SoonOui HTML, PDF, JPG, PNGOui HTML+javascript, PDF, imageOuiOui PDF, PNG, JPG, VDXOui Export to PDF or JPG, plus export summary of annotationsOui PNG, PDF, PPT and HTML5Oui PDF, PNG, ZIP of PNG(many screens)Oui PDF,PNG,Slideshow (EXE),XMLOuiOui PDF, XPS, PNG, JPG, WMF, EPS, WMV, ...Oui PDF, PNG, POS.Oui Export to HTML archive, Web URL, or Word Doc SpecOuiOui JPG, PNG, PDF, HTML
Drag and Drop componentsOuiOuiOui In future releaseOuiOuiOuiOuiOui 3400 widgetsOuiOuiOui Also quick add in place (alt+click/drag).OuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOui over 100 components,over 40 mobile componentsOuiOuiOuiOui Amazing Shape library with shapes for drag and drop.OuiOui
Mockups saved asfile.asap filesRP-filesBMML filesHTML5
  • HTML
  • Adobe PDF
  • Images (PNG, GIF, JPEG)
Preview, can send link to preview or link to entire project to anyone with a Fluid UI account.4ui filesCustom XML Schemasfile, html or imageonline + HTMLonline, or export to PDF or JPGJSON / XMLMBX, also export to png/pdf/exe/PowerPoint file (.pptx, .ppt)Interactive online prototype, interactive offline prototype, or Word spec.Can be exported as JPG, PNG, PDF and HTML. The work done in the app is saved automatically online (UXPin is a cloud service).
Embeddable WireframeOuiOuiOuiOui Live/Dynamic Integration in Indigo Storyboards, with Real-World ScenesOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOui SupportedOuiOui
Live PreviewOuiOuiOuiOui Via presentation modeOui Tethering view and launch come soon.OuiOuiOui DefinitelyOuiOui With additional feature to set a password for access via link.
WindowsOuiOui Adobe AIR basedOui Windows 2000, XP, 2003 Server, Vista, or 7OuiOuiOuiOuiOui Windows 95, 98, Me, NT 4.0, 2000, XP, or Vista, including the Tablet PCOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOui with Firefox, Chrome, IE, Opera, Safari etc.OuiOui web-basedOui Web (Flash)Oui Web and Silverlight basedOui Desktop version. web version come soon.OuiNonOuiOuiOui Add-on for Microsoft PowerPoint 2007/2010Oui Web app.Oui Web-basedOuiOui Cloud, browser-based
Mac OSOuiOui Adobe AIR basedOui Mac OS X 10.5+OuiOuiOuiOuiOui Mac OS X 10.2OuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOuiOui with Firefox, Chrome, IE, Opera, Safari etcOuiOui web-basedOui Web (Flash)Oui Web and Silverlight basedOui Desktop version.web version come soon.OuiOuiOuiNonOui Web-basedOuiOui Cloud, browser-based
LinuxOuiNonOuiOuiOuiNonOui Solaris, Linux, and other Unix-like operating systemsOuiOuiOuiNon- Works fine if you use WINEOui with Firefox, Chrome, IE, Opera, Safari etcOuiOui web-basedOui Web (Flash)Oui Web and Silverlight basedOui Web version come soon.NonNonOuiNonOui Web-basedOuiOui Cloud, browser-based
Site webhttp://www.alouka.comhttp://www.appsketcher.com
  • 2010-09-05 09:11:52
    2015-10-08 22:14:44
  • English
  • Compare les outils de prototypage: Axure vs Balsamiq, Cacoo, Concept Draw, Denim, Designer Vista, FairBuilder, ForeUI, HotGloo, Inpreso, iPlotz, Justinmind, Justproto, Lumzy, MockFlow, Mocking Bird, MockLinkr, Napkee, ProtoShare, Simulify...
  • Publique
  • Creative Commons License CC-BY-SA 3.0 / GNU FDL
    Gérer les sauvegardes


  • a noté Pidoco: Note globale 5
    Love this tool!
    English Posté 2015-10-06 13:32:07 par Social
  • a voté pour Pidoco (J'aime)
    Posté 2015-10-06 13:31:45 par Social
  • For me the best to make all kind of schema and share with co-workers
    Posté 2015-09-14 09:09:20 par Guy Olivier
  • a voté pour LucidChart (J'aime)
    Really great UI, that allows to make schema during meeting in real time. Great for sharing and integration with Google docs.
    Posté 2015-09-14 09:08:33 par Guy Olivier
  • a voté pour ForeUI (J'aime)
    this app is awesome!
    English Posté 2015-08-26 02:50:51 par GeneSD
  • Posté 2015-07-23 16:00:41 par eileen
  • a voté pour Indigo Studio (J'aime)
    Posté 2015-06-22 12:28:11 par RussRothstein
  • a voté pour LucidChart (J'aime)
    Posté 2015-05-20 16:22:24 par Jaxson Elliott
  • a voté pour Mockup Builder (J'aime)
    Posté 2015-05-15 20:56:13 par bakghost
  • suggère de modifier Mockup Builder en mettant la valeur de Offre gratuite à no
    English Posté 2015-04-13 00:45:32 par lolmaus
  • suggère de modifier Mockup Builder en mettant la valeur de Offre gratuite à no
    English Posté 2015-04-13 00:45:24 par lolmaus
  • Posté 2015-04-13 00:40:54 par lolmaus
  • a noté UXPin: Note globale 5
    Posté 2015-04-13 00:40:45 par lolmaus
  • a voté pour UXPin (J'aime)
    Posté 2015-04-13 00:39:41 par lolmaus
  • a voté pour Mocking Bird (J'aime)
    Posté 2015-04-13 00:39:31 par lolmaus
  • suggère de modifier Alouka en mettant la valeur de Nom à Feydor
    Posté 2015-04-08 13:38:31 par gorkor
  • suggère de modifier Alouka en mettant la valeur de Nom à Feydor
    Posté 2015-04-08 13:38:18 par gorkor
  • Hi, I would suggest adding to the list as a faster way to create hi and low fidelity mobile app and wearable prototypes using just a drag and drop tool. You can share with your team and clients for fast feedback or try it on your own phone. It has custom built libraries for most platforms and has extensive libraries for wearable app design. Thanks, Eileen (from fluidui)
    English Posté 2015-03-09 14:12:18 par eileen
  • a voté pour Pidoco (J'aime)
    Pidoco is awsome
    English Posté 2015-02-26 16:35:14 par cbou
  • a voté pour Savah App (J'aime)
    Great tool we are using SavahApp on all our projects. I would suggest checking it out
    English Posté 2014-12-11 19:27:31 par Dave
  • Posté 2014-12-04 23:49:52 par SavahAapp
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-11-26 18:20:17 par TonyReake
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-11-26 18:18:40 par NikolasHezer
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-11-26 18:15:58 par OstinKlen
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-11-26 18:11:09 par DarsiKine
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-11-26 18:09:29 par GoldiBad
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-11-26 18:04:39 par BettiDaren
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-11-26 18:01:13 par AkenBruk
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-11-26 17:55:04 par AleksVilmar
  • a voté pour MockupScreens (J'aime)
    First like - from the author :)
    English Posté 2014-11-04 16:52:16 par IgorJ
  • a voté pour Balsamiq Mockups (J'aime)
    I have used Balsamiq extensively. I think it is an awesome tool. It lets you create mockups quickly, has a lot of supporting widgets and a nice online collaboration platform.
    English Posté 2014-08-27 17:15:38 par natiyer
  • I recently discovered a great wire-framing tool called Visual Spec. I really think it should be included in your line up. It absolutely free at
    English Posté 2014-08-12 16:55:21 par imane
  • a voté pour Justinmind (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-07-31 04:02:56 par Dave
  • a noté UXPin: Note globale 2
    Neat idea, but very broken. Too many bugs that destroy or damage mockups.
    English Posté 2014-07-31 04:02:31 par Dave
  • Very good, especially compared to UXPin. About Justinmind: • Excellent layer/group management. Clearly aiming at Photoshop in this regard. • Fast. • Stable: no crashes, and so far, only one weird little bug encountered (the order of elements in a group sometimes gets reversed, but fixes itself after putting the "last" element at the top, where it belongs.) • Comparable commenting system to UXPin. About UXPin • Near feature-parity with Justinind. • Very unstable (bugs, bugs, and more bugs: new ones every day!) I have had many hours' work destroyed by "smart elements" suddenly "exploding" all over the page. Copies of mock-ups lose grouping, making the groups useless. • Because it's cloud-based, very sluggish: uploading a small icon graphic can take several *minutes* before the image is usable in a mockup. • Terrible layers implementation: All but impossible to select items that are behind other items without moving the "upper" items out of the way. ZERO layer management. None.
    English Posté 2014-07-31 04:01:48 par Dave
  • Great options, but you should also try Lucidchart's wireframe design tool! You can check it out at
    English Posté 2014-07-24 04:03:21 par Whitemarcy9
  • One of my favorites software tools, starting since 1982(?). One of those tools that you love to use because it makes you feel like you can do anything fast.
    English Posté 2014-07-23 15:45:53 par Jack Bellis
  • suggère de modifier Pencil Firefox Add on en mettant la valeur de Nom à Pencil (possible Add on : chrome, Firefox)
    Posté 2014-06-30 17:46:46 par fabacks
  • Posté 2014-06-30 17:45:07 par fabacks
  • a noté Axure: Note globale 5
    Posté 2014-05-01 14:36:10 par jas
  • a voté pour ce Comparatif (J'aime)
    what a great comparison!! Thank you.
    English Posté 2014-05-01 14:31:33 par jas
  • Hi @Andreas Herren, I have restored the previous version (list of criteria). Best regards, Vanina
    English Posté 2014-03-17 14:03:54 par Vanina
  • made an error. how can i restore an older version?
    English Posté 2014-03-17 13:27:40 par Andreas Herren
  • i love this tool
    English Posté 2014-03-14 18:18:46 par Oleh A Mykhayloych
  • a voté pour Mockup Builder (J'aime)
    great one!
    English Posté 2014-03-14 18:18:36 par Oleh A Mykhayloych
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2014-02-20 14:26:19 par Marie Coop
  • Posté 2014-02-20 14:26:15 par Marie Coop
  • Posté 2013-12-11 15:14:37 par Mark1
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2013-12-11 15:14:29 par Mark1
  • a voté pour Concept Draw (J'aime)
    Posté 2013-12-10 13:27:18 par MosesFriedric
voir les commentaires plus anciens

Laisser un commentaire

Créer des tableaux comparatifs ou listes sur tout !

C'est gratuit et rapide de créer des tableaux originaux

Créer un tableau