Compare 433MHz vs 868MHz vs 916MHz vs Zigbee vs Z-Wave vs 6LowPan vs LONworks vs Powerline vs Homeplug vs Bluetooth vs EnOcean vs ONE-NET vs X10 vs GPRS vs GSM vs 3G vs 4G LTE vs Wi-fi vs Bluetooth vs NFC vs DASH7 vs Wireless KNX
Nom abrégé | 6LoWPAN | Bluetooth | DASH7 | EnOcean | Weightless-N | SigFox | Wi-Fi | Wireless KNX | Wireless M-BUS | Z-Wave | Zigbee |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Détails techniques | |||||||||||
| Frequencies | 2.4GHz, 915Mhz (Americas), 868Mhz (Europe) | 2.4GHz | 433 MHz (Europe) | 868MHz (Europe) 315 / 902 MHz (Americas) | 868Mhz (Europe) 915Mhz (Americas) | 868Mhz (Europe) 915Mhz (Americas) | 2.4GHz, 5GHz 802.11n | 868Mhz (Europe) | 169 MHz (Europe), 433 MHz (Europe), 868Mhz(Europe) | 919.82MHz (Hong Kong), 908.42MHz ISM band (United States), 868.42MHz SRD Band (Europe), | 2.4GHz, 915Mhz (Americas), 868Mhz (Europe) |
| Latency | 6 ms | 2s | |||||||||
| Broadcast range | 10 m | 2 km | 30 m : indoor 300 m : outdoor | 5 km | 15 km outdoor | 250 m | 30 m indoor | 10 m : indoor 100 m : outdoor | |||
| Available sensor ranges | |||||||||||
| Available actuator range | |||||||||||
| Ad hoc networking capabilities | yes | ||||||||||
| Battery Life | |||||||||||
| Security | E0 stream cipher | AES-128 | AES-128 or ARC4 | WPA2 | AES-128 | ||||||
| interoperability | yes | ||||||||||
| Other details | |||||||||||
| Open / Closed / Proprietary standard | Open | ISO/IEC 18000-7 open standard | Proprietary published ISO/IEC 14543-3-10 standard | Open | Proprietary | Open standard | Proprietary published ISO/IEC 14543-3 standard European Standard (CENELEC EN50090 and CEN EN 13321-1 and 13321-2) | EN 13757-4 | IEEE 802.15.4 open standard | ||
| Geographic adoption | |||||||||||
| Known technical issues | |||||||||||
| Tarifs | |||||||||||
| Board costs (USD) | |||||||||||
| Licensing costs (USD) | |||||||||||
| Ressources | |||||||||||
| Site web | ietf.org/... | bluetooth.com | dash7.org | enocean.com/... | weightless.org/... | sigfox.com | wi-fi.org | knx.org | m-bus.com | z-wave.com | zigbee.org |
| Wikipédia | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... | wikipedia.org/... |
Avis utilisateurs et commentaires
A useful summary comparison but lacks some detail.